Depeche Mode – “But Not Tonight”:
A Rain-Soaked Reprieve from the Darkness
Released in 1986 as the B-side to their single “Stripped” in the UK, Depeche Mode’s “But Not Tonight” took on a whole different life in the United States. Over there, it was flipped to become the A-side, largely because it popped up on the soundtrack for the romantic comedy Modern Girls. While “Stripped” was all brooding and industrial, “But Not Tonight” offered something completely unexpected: a bright, melodic synth-pop track that just celebrated the quiet joy of being alone and feeling alive.
A Lighter Side of the Mode
Written by Martin Gore and sung by Dave Gahan, the song kicks off with a line that perfectly sets the mood: “Oh God, it’s raining / But I’m not complaining.” It’s a declaration of emotional renewal, of finding beauty in solitude and the sensory experience of a rainy night. The lyrics gently touch on past pain—“When my eyes had been so red / I’d been mistaken for dead”—but sharply contrast it with a newfound sense of vitality: “But not tonight.”
Musically, “But Not Tonight” is upbeat and shimmering, with bright synth lines and a really danceable rhythm. This makes it stand out against the darker textures often found in their Black Celebration era. It’s one of those rare Depeche Mode tracks from the mid-80s that feels openly optimistic, even a little playful, without losing any of its emotional depth.
Enduring Impact
Even though it wasn’t a huge chart hit, the song really resonated with fans and gained a cult following—especially in the U.S. There, it became a favorite on alternative radio and in clubs. Its spot in Modern Girls helped introduce the band to a wider audience, and the track has popped up on several compilations and reissues since then.
“But Not Tonight” remains a fan favorite for its emotional honesty and melodic charm. It’s a sweet reminder that even in a band known for its darkness and introspection, Depeche Mode could still find the light—and even dance in the rain.